Compare and contrast the three traditional models of abnormal behavior: supernatural, psychological, and biological. Mention significant events and persons in the historical development of each model
What will be an ideal response?
For much of our recorded history, the supernatural tradition described deviant behavior as a reflection of the battle between good and evil. During the last quarter of the 14th century, religious and lay authorities supported these popular superstitions, and society as a whole began to believe more strongly in the existence and power of demons and witches. Treatments included exorcism, in which various religious rituals were performed to rid the victim of evil spirits. Other approaches included shaving the pattern of a cross in the hair of the victim's head and securing sufferers to a wall near the front of a church so that they might benefit from hearing Mass.
An equally strong opinion reflected the view that insanity was a natural phenomenon, caused by mental or emotional stress, and was curable. Common treatments were rest, sleep, and a healthy environment. Other treatments included baths, ointments, and various potions.
Paracelsus, a Swiss physician who lived from 1493 to 1541, rejected notions of possession by the devil, suggesting instead that the movements of the moon and stars had profound effects on people's psychological functioning. This influential theory inspired the word lunatic, which is derived from the Latin word for moon, luna.
With the biological tradition, physical causes of mental disorders have been sought since antiquity. The Greek physician Hippocrates (460–377 B.C.) and others suggested that psychological disorders could be treated like any other disease. They believed psychological disorders might also be caused by brain pathology or head trauma and could be influenced by heredity (genetics). Hippocrates considered the brain to be the seat of wisdom, consciousness, intelligence, and emotion. Therefore, disorders involving these functions would logically be located in the brain. Hippocrates also recognized the importance of psychological and interpersonal contributions to psychopathology.
The Roman physician Galen (approximately 129–198 A.D.) adopted these ideas and developed them further, creating an influential school of thought that extended well into the 19th century. Physicians believed that disease resulted from too much or too little of one of the humors; for example, too much black bile was thought to cause melancholia (depression). The humoral theory was, perhaps, the first example of associating psychological disorders with a "chemical imbalance," an approach that is widespread today.
The psychological tradition has a long tradition. Plato, for example, thought that the two causes of maladaptive behavior were the social and cultural influences in one's life and the learning that took place in that environment. If something was wrong in the environment, such as abusive parents, one's impulses and emotions would overcome reason. The best treatment was to reeducate the individual so that reason would predominate.
During the first half of the 19th century, a psychosocial approach called moral therapy became influential. Its tenets included treating patients as normally as possible in a setting that encouraged social interaction. Pussin had already removed chains used to restrain patients and instituted humane psychological interventions. Pussin persuaded Pinel to go along with the changes.
After William Tuke (1732–1822) followed Pinel's lead in England, Benjamin Rush (1745–1813), often considered the founder of American psychiatry, introduced moral therapy at Pennsylvania Hospital. Asylums had appeared in the 16th century, but they were more like prisons than hospitals. Dorothea Dix (1802–1887) campaigned for reform in the treatment of insanity. Having worked in various institutions, she had firsthand knowledge of the deplorable conditions imposed on patients with insanity, and she made it her life's work to inform the American public of these abuses. Her work became known as the mental hygiene movement. An unforeseen consequence of Dix's heroic efforts was a substantial increase in the number of mental patients. This influx led to a rapid transition from moral therapy to custodial care.
You might also like to view...
For no reason, Matthew started to pay special attention to a girl named Madison, a girl in his homeroom class, from the first day of school. This is one example of the _____ principle of attraction and relationship formation
A) proximity B) similarity C) reciprocity D) serendipity
The idea that certain areas of the brainstem can send out signals to fibers connected to the spinal cord and effectively block pain is part of the ______ theory of pain
a. cerebral control c. pattern b. gate control d. primary receptor