To estimate dynamic causal effects, your textbook presents the distributed lag regression model, the autoregressive distributed lag model, and a quasi-difference representation of the distributed lag model with autoregressive errors
Using a simple example, such as a distributed lag model with only the current and past value of X and an AR(1) model for the error term, discuss how these models are related. In each case suggest estimation methods and evaluate the relative merit in using one rather than the other.
What will be an ideal response?
Answer: The student's answer should follow the discussion in section 13.2-13.3 (distributed lag model) and 13.5 (autoregressive distributed lag model and quasi-difference representation of the distributed lag model with autoregressive errors). Major points which should include the assumption of exogeneity in the case of the distributed lag model, which, together with the other distributed lag model assumptions, allows for the dynamic multiplier and cumulative dynamic multiplier estimation by OLS. Given the AR(1) nature of the error term, the importance of using HAC standard errors should be stressed.
For the ADL and quasi-difference representation, the importance of the strictly exogenous regressor assumption must be emphasized. The answer should include the derivation of the dynamic multipliers from the OLS estimated ADL coefficients and the difference between the infeasible and feasible GLS estimator. For the latter, the Cochrane-Orcutt procedure should be mentioned.
If the regressors are strictly exogenous, then GLS is asymptotically BLUE. However, since the ADL specification requires estimation of fewer parameters, it may be preferred in practice. If there is no convincing argument for the regressor being strictly exogenous, but an argument for exogeneity can be made, then OLS estimation using HAC standard errors is the preferred method.
You might also like to view...
Proponents of the real business cycle model argue that the short-run aggregate supply curve is
A) flat. B) negatively sloped. C) positively sloped. D) vertical.
Gross domestic product includes
A. your purchase of 100 shares of Alibaba. B. your gift of $100 to your brother. C. your purchase of a gently used 1990 Porsche Carrera. D. your weekly paycheck as a server at Denny’s.