A speaker is addressing a diverse gathering at a graduation ceremony at a public

school in her hometown.

She uses the opportunity of a captive audience to warn the
graduating class and their parents that if they do not adhere to the teachings of her
specific religion, they will suffer forever in the afterlife. In terms of her ethical obligation
to her listeners, how would we evaluate the speaker's appeal?
A) It is good—as well as often productive—to offend, especially a captive audience.
B) She recognizes that the truth hurts sometimes but still must be spoken and heard.
C) She is justified; she has employed the means necessary to arouse great passion.
D) Some listeners will likely view her remarks as tasteless and of poor judgment.

D